News 
 National News 
 National 
 General 
 'Dwelling crankily' on sex abuse case: bishop 

'Dwelling crankily' on sex abuse case: bishop

16/07/2008 3:32:00 PM
The co-ordinator of World Youth Day, Bishop Anthony Fisher, today responded to a question about Cardinal George Pell's handling of a sexual abuse case by saying people are "dwelling crankily ... on old wounds".

His comments came after ABC's Lateline last night reported on Anthony Foster, whose daughters were raped by Melbourne priest Kevin O'Donnell when they were in primary school.

Mr Foster alleged Cardinal Pell stalled the family's compensation claim against the Catholic Church when he was archbishop of Melbourne.

Asked about the broadcast, Bishop Fisher told this morning's World Youth Day press conference: "The cardinal and I were otherwise occupied last night enjoying the youth festival so we didn't see the Lateline story.

"All I've seen is the reports in the newspapers today.

"Happily, I think most of Australia was enjoying [and] delighting in the beauty and goodness of these young people and the hope for us doing these sorts of things better in the future, as we saw last night, rather than dwelling crankily, as a few people are doing, on old wounds."

He said Cardinal Pell had led the church in trying to put in place better processes to deal with sexual abuse claims.

"I am convinced that he has done all he can and will continue to receive, as I hear today that was suggested on Lateline, some ways that we might improve processes for the future.

"We are happy to hear any constructive advice on how we can do this better in the future. In the meantime to do all we can to prevent this happening again and to bring healing and justice to the victims of these terrible cases."

He could not say if Cardinal Pell would meet Mr Foster, but said Cardinal Pell had a long history of meeting victims of clerical sexual abuse.

"He is very open to meeting victims. And if that can be constructive, if there can be a genuine conversation, I suspect again he is a generous and compassionate man and he will want to do what he can to heal these victims as any others."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size



Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
This low man, no different from Cardinal Pell, and the Catholic institution, sicken me. As I see it, utterly repulsive - no shame, no empathy, no guilt and no understanding, but calculated callousness, undeserved pride and deliberate ignorance abound. My heart breaks for the lives of those people destroyed by the actions of these deluded, sanctimonious b***ds.
Posted by Justice on 16/07/2008 5:09:17 PM
It is plainly astonishing to me how out of touch some of the high profile senior clergy of the Catholic Church in Australia seem to be. Not only are Bishop Fisher's comments immediately insulting to the victims of childhood sexual abuse by members of the clergy, they reveal a deeper and more insidious malaise that is characterized by a callous insensitivity and a lack of willingness to acknowledge the on going needs of those damaged whilst in the Church's care. I sense the absence of a pastoral heart within the upper echelons of the body of Christ. That this carelessness of thought and word is displayed amidst the euphoria of World Youth Day activities can only add to the sadness of those who once innocently attended such gatherings to their loss. When will Bishop Fisher and his ilk learn that the suffering perpetrated by sexual predators upon children endures for a lifetime and that victims and their families have every right to be "cranky", living with "old wounds" that simply will not heal. Reading the Bishop's comments underlines an all too obvious unwillingness on the part of the religious elite to see the consequences of sexual abuse as anything more than a temporary irritation that may be paid out and hopefully thereby silenced. I despair at the thought that the Church as represented by Bishop Fisher in his unfortunate comments, has not only harbored and protected pedophiles in the past, it now continues to punish their victims in the present with an unparalleled indifference. It seems to me that World Youth Day (the worthy celebration that it is), is cynically viewed by some as an opportunity to try to spin a smoke screen around the pain and suffering of the innocent.
Posted by slaney on 16/07/2008 5:24:19 PM
I agree that Bishop Fisher should not have said this as it isn't just about the Father of the daughters who is kicking Pell in the teeth. Other victims could find the remark hurtful. Fisher is wrong to say it but what he said isn't wrong. Focussing on the positive can be benefitial to people and someone who comes over from England to bad mouth Pell after getting an apology and an offer of money but choosing to drag his daughters through court to maximise his profit at any cost is really a candidate for such advice. Pell has done the right thing even paying for one girl's counselling while her dad was dragging her through court but this character continues to kick Pell in the teeth. The father is a good illustration of the 90-10 rule. If he wasn't so interested in profitting his daughters would have raped but nothing further. Now look what has happened. I suspect that Fisher is friends with Pell and was thus too angry to properly consider his words. Yes the guy is a victim but that is no excuse to make Pell one too. Two wrongs don't make a right. (Nor do three - something Fisher needs to realize.)
Posted by deni on 18/07/2008 10:01:12 AM
Interesting. A doctor who has examined me and who knows about the PTSD and profound depression I have experienced since being assaulted (not by a priest) told me that my lifespan could be reduced by 10 or twenty years due to the grief and stress which I have been suffering since the 1970s. But I suppose that I shouldn't dwell on this, OR on the financial, emotional and other impacts this crime has had on me, my parents, my husband, my three children and my friends.
Posted by Felix on 28/07/2008 2:22:27 PM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Bishop Anthony Fisher and, inset, Katherine, Emma and Anthony Foster.
Bishop Anthony Fisher and, inset, Katherine, Emma and Anthony Foster.


4:31 PM AEDT | US president-elect Barack Obama inherits the in-box from hell, but an all-points crisis such as the present one also creates opportunities for radical change that do not exist in normal times.
Butler and Pollock
 
D & D Services
 
Term Deposit
 
Illawarra Mercury Drive
 
Hunter Valley Wine Country
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...